12 Comments

• mhut gefregt bai a rov?

  Dachtzas meer az “full fledged hypnosis” iz nisht oisgehalten baim rebbin

  Di they get a hetter?

  To temporerily suspend ones free will maybe problematic

• z

  its free will to temporarily suspend your free will.., otherwise its not free will..

• Perplexed

  It was my understanding from Rabbi Groner that the Rebbe is against hypnosis -very confused as to why our camps would endorse and allow this to happen?

• To remporeriy suspend ur free will is a shaila

  To voluntarily submit to “suggestion” is a problem

  Albeit very very entertaining

  The Rebbe generally did not allow the use of Hypnosys due to the fact that it requires the temporary suspension of ones will

• Fake

  None of these kids were hypnotized. They were playing along and pretending. The guy is an entertainer, not a real hypnotist.

• Skeptic

  And the educational value of this, is what?
  If it is real, u have big problems. If it is fake, so what is the message? To bluff?
  We have enough bluff.
  In Nevel, I don’t recall we had this kind of show. We had a farmer bring his cow and showed us how to milk. It was authentic, halachically acceptable, and perfectly entertaining.

  • Mosad

    I agree.

  • And then you snapped out of it...

    He must have been a talented hypnotist to make you think that you were in Nevel watching a cow get milked!

• We made a mistake

  We should have consulted a Rov!

  That’s good advice in general, to run things by a Rav and educational body,

• Oh please

  First of all, without a source any quotes are invalid.
  When, where and in what context did the Rebbe say that?!

  What educational value does it have?
  The same value as sports.
  14 year old boys where not programmed to learn all day…

• Skeptic

  Sports are excercise and a long accepted form of recreation for young students. With This show you have entered a new realm, the realm of entertainment. Now you have to start asking questions as was done above. Your answer is empty and faulty. Try again.
  But I still love u, cuz it’s the Nine days and you’re essentially a nice guy.

• anno

  is that levi?