Weekly Story: The Heilike Ruzhiner
by Rabbi Sholom DovBer Avtzon
This past Monday, the 3rd of Cheshvan was the yahrzeit of the Heilike Ruzhiner, Reb Yisroel Friedman. In this weeks’ post we will note one famous story of his interactions with the Alter Rebbe.
As always, your feedback and comments are most welcomed and appreciated.
As is known the Alter Rebbe travel around Russia and Ukraine extensively. and doing one of those trips he came to the city where the Ruzhiner was living (Prohbist). At that time, Reb Yisroel was a young child of five or seven years old.
Many people of the city came out to greet the Alter Rebbe and the young Israel was amongst them. Seeing the Alter Rebbe he went over and had a short conversation with him, (some say he climbed into his wagon). Sometime later, the Alter Rebbe said to his Chassidim, a young boy asked me a question that none of the chassidim have asked me. He then clarified what the question was.
The child asked me, after a Jew says the Possuk of Shema Yisroel, how is it possible that he feels that he is an entity separate from Hashem and therefore is commanded to love Hashem. When a Jew says Shema Yisroel, he is declaring that Hashem is the only true entity in this world and everything in it, is only an extension of Hashem. So if I am an extension of Hashem I’m not a separate entity, who loves a greater entity. [The Torah is not instructing us to love ourself!]
Hearing this question the chassidin wanted to know what was the answer that the Alter Rebbe gave him. So either they asked the Alter Rebbe himself or they went to the young boy and asked him what did the Maggid of Liozna, as the Alter Rebbe was then known, tell you.
The reply was, you are correct in your question; the first possuk of Shema states that there is nothing else besides Hashem. However, before we say the Possek of Vi’ahavta, our sages instructed us to add and say the Possuk of Boruch Shem.. and that possuk informs us that Hashem desires that initially we should feel independent of him and therefore when we serve Him we will be doing so out of our own desire and not that we feel overwhelmed by His greatness.
So after you say the possuk of Boruch Shem, you are supposed to feel as if your body is somewhat separate from Hashem and then you have the Commandment of Vi’ahavta, coming to love Hashem to such an extent that you no longer feel that you are independent of Him, but you want to be connected with Him at the highest level, and even if that will cause you to give up your life.
A taste of Chassidus of Chassidus
Ani Hinei Bi’risi E’tuch 5744
The possuk states that Hashem promised Avrohom, now that you have had a circumcision, I am making a covenant with you; You will rule over the Nations.
The question is why was this reward given to Avrohom only after having his circumcision and not before that?
Our sages tell us that Avrohom was the epitome of kindness, to the extent that the sphere of kindness said to Hashem ever since Avrohom was in the world, I have nothing to do. Avrohom extended kindness to all. In other words he extended kindness even before he was commanded to have a bris. And in his generation when he and his family were the only Jews, it is evident that his acts of kindness were to the nations of the Earth.
Being that the angel on high complained that he has no work to occupy himself with, that means that not only did Avrohom do physical acts of kindness as serving food to people who were traveling and in need, but also kindness in a spiritual sense.
The Midrash tells us that a spiritual kindness of his was, that before Avraham had a circumcision elevated Souls (souls of tzaddikim) were given even to the other nations. One of the examples given is Mi’ooshelach: not only was he the longest living person recorded but because of his greatness the flood was delayed not only until he passed away, but even for the 7 days after his passing. However, once Avraham had a Bris milah, then no longer were these elevated Souls of righteous people given into other nations.
A second explanation of what the covenant was is, that once Avrohom had a Bris he is considered the father of every convert. Therefore, a man that converts is called the son of Abraham and a woman that converts is the daughter of Sarah. This explains why we find the aspect of converts after Avrohoms bris, and not before then. Being that before his circumcision exalted Souls were also given to the nations of the Earth, therefore, they did not feel any need to become close to Hashem through conversion, as some of them already had an exalted soul, that connected them to a certain degree to Hashem.
However, after having his bris, which caused that the other Nations no longer received these exalted Souls, therefore some of them would feel a urge and desire to become closer to Hashem and the only way they were able to accomplish that, was by becoming a convert, and that was the covenant that Hashem made, a convert is his child.
We can Now understand something perplexing. One of the basic tenants of Chassidus and emphasis is that every descent is in order that it gives an opportunity for that thing to become elevated to a higher level. So now that the nations of the Earth were no longer able to receive these exalted Souls the question becomes what elevation was a consequence of that descent?
But as noted, now there are many converts and before then there were no converts. So this descent of theirs is impetus of desiring to become completely connected to Hashem by converting.
This also explains another interesting aspect. We find that the vast majority of converts are from the descendants of Esau, which in general encompasses Europe ( Western Civilization), while we do not have that many converts from the descendants of Ishmael, even though originally we were exiled to their lands.
But based on the above it is understood. Being that Yishmael was born before his father Avrohom had a bris, when he was born there was a possibility for him to receive an exalted righteous soul, so in his DNA, there isn’t the feeling of a need to come closer to Hashem, hence there are no or a very limited amount of converts among his descendants. Whereas, Esau was born after Avrohom and Yitzchok had a bris, so in his children’s DNA, there is the gene, that tells them that the way to become connected to Hashem is by becoming a convert.
Rabbi Avtzon is a veteran mechanech and the author of numerous books on the Rebbeim and their chassidim. He is available to farbreng in your community and can be contacted at avtzonbooks@gmail.com Posted in honor of the wedding of Shmuel and Esti Rosenblatt.
1. The Ruzhiner’s father, Reb Sholom Shachna was a son of Reb Avrhom Hamalach, the son of the Maggid. His mother was a granddaughter of Reb Menachem Nochum of Chernobyl.
2. Being that the Ruzhiner was born on the third of Tishrei 5557 (1796), this occurred either in 5562 or 5564. Reb Yisroel’s father Reb Sholom Shachna was nistalek in the year of 5563.
3. The deeper meanings and the difference between the possuk of Shema Yisroel and Borch Shem, is explained by the Alter Rebbe in Sgaar HaYichud Ve’Haemunah (the second section of the Tanya).
There he explains that in the possuk of Shema, we are declaring that Hashem is not only the source of everything, but IS evrthing, as there is nothing besides Him.
In the second possuk, we explain, that while the first possuk is absolutely true, however, in order that the world should serve Hashem on their own and as a robot or an overwhelming awareness of His presence, because He is revealed to all, therefore Hashem conceals His greatness, and we can and will come to that recognition, through our effort and toil to become closer to Him.
Mushkie
Since malochim are more spiritual than humans, for them to separate from Hashem, they need to say Boruch shem out loud (as we, on Yom Kippur).
Bochur
The context of Boruch Shem is that Moshe “stole” it from the malochim. It is a valuable addition, that we say quietly to hide that it was “stolen
. To say that Boruch Shem LOWERS one’s connection with Hashem seems counter-intuitive.
Mushkie
Rabbi, a question came up (relating to your article), seeking insight, why do we say Boruch Sheim THREE times after Neilah? Is there significance to the 3 times?
Mushkie
The Rebbitzen in our group said because it is for Hashem melech, Hashem molach, Hashem yimloch (source Levush Orach Chayim 623:6 ), therefore the malchus of Kvod Malchuso is represented in past, present and future. If one skips boruch shem when reciting Shema, the Bach says the shema is valid, but Levush says the shema is invalid. The Levush fits well with your article. The Bach – not so well.
Mushkie
A point was raised that if someone makes a brocha in vain, she should say Boruch Shem. Apparently, praising Hashem by reciting Boruch Shem, “rectifies” saying his name in vain. Some in group suggested that if one does not reach true Shema Yisroel and become One with Him, we MUST add Boruch Shem to rectify this vain statement. Any insight to add (based on article)?
Rabbi Shalom Avtzon
As you can see there are many aspects to this topic of Boruch Shem, and I am not going to go into all the details. This is something to be discussed in a (Chassidus) class and not on a little chat in a Column about stories.
However, it is evident that those who are posting feel more comfortable asking me than their teacher or mashpia. So I would like to bring out a few points and please discuss it with your teacher or mashpia for clarification.
You have mentioned that Yaakov Avinu said it, as well as the fact that Moshe Raibeinu heard the angels saying it. However, there is another source for it.
Rashi in Haazinoo on the possuk.Ki Shem Hashem Ekrah- when I call out the name if Hashem, give greatness to our G-d, says that when one hears Hashem’s holy name, give praise to Him. Therefore, when the Jews in the Beis hamidrash heard the Kohen Godol saying Hashem’s holy name, everybody present said, the possuk of Boruch Shem.
The commentaries explained this is the reason why we say Boruch Shem if the person mentioned hashem’s name in vain. Because the passage said that when Hashem’s name is mentioned give praise. Therefore we say the praise of Boruch Shrm declaring He created the universe, and it wasn’t said in vain. Now the possuk says give greatness to Hashem, the question is what is Hashem’s greatness?
Chassidus explains, that in order for Hashem to create the world, He had to lower and humble Himself to accomplish that and that is His greatness. So as I mentioned in the column, Boruch Shem is connected to the creation of the world. However, when a person who is a physical human being, follows his bodily desires and not spiritual pursuits, at that point it is improper for him to say that Hashem is everything when he is going against Hashem’s will. Therefore our sages did not know if we should say Boruch Shem or not. On one hand, our soul is on t
the level to say it, as a soul is higher than an angel. On the other hand, the body should not say it because the body might not act in tune with that statement. Therefore we don’t say it out loud because that is revealing the statement and the body which is revealed may not be able to say it, but we say it quietly, just as the nishama is not seen and the neshoma could say it.
However, on Yom Kippur when we separate ourselves from bodily pursuits, we say it loudly, just as Yaakov Avinu was able to say iy outloud.
Finally, the possuk of Shema Yisroel, as noted is stating that Hashem is the only entity. He is the one and only. Therefore, by Neila we say Shema only once. The possuk of Boruch Shem, is expressing how Hashem lowered Himself into creating this world. In other words that process began in His thoughts, in his wisdom, knowledge and understanding. Therefore, to correspond to the three levels of Chochmah, Bina and Dass, we say it three times.
Hashem Hu Elokim, is referring to the seven spheres from the sphere of Chesed, which was the foundation of creating the world, through the seventh sphere of Malchus, which is the actual creation. Therefore we say those words seven times.
This is only scratching the surface, but I hope it clarified many aspects.
Mushkie
Rabbi, Thank you, as always. You don’t just scratch the surface”, you add depth and broadness which enrich the readers. Sometimes your insightful comments are more meaningful to the readers than the original article! On behalf of many, THANKS!!!