Report: Iron Dome System Failure Led to Deaths

It is now being reported that the rocket attack deaths in Nachlat Har Chabad (a neighborhood in the southern Israeli town of Kiryat Malachi) last week were the result of a half-hour failure in the Iron dome rocket interception system that morning.

According to a Haaretz report, a malfunction in the system was detected that disrupted the rocket defense system from functioning properly for a half hour period. It was during that fatal half hour that the rockets were launched into Kiryat Malachi.

Haaretz quotes senior Defense Ministry official Yair Ramati as saying “when there is a malfunction, the team receives notification and addresses it. Most malfunctions are technical and do not result in system malfunction. There is nothing that is 100%. No system can deliver 100%.

JTA: Fear, Rage and Resilience in Kiryat Malachi Amid the Rocket Fire

They pick through the tangled foliage, Orthodox men with long beards and black kipahs, wearing white gloves and bright yellow vests, searching for body parts.

A few yards over and four stories up, construction workers drive drills into a bombed apartment building. They speak to each other in Arabic. Can they read the Hebrew banner hanging one floor above them vowing to exact a price for Jewish blood? Or the sign on the other side of the building calling on Israel to conquer Gaza?

Noon has just passed on Friday — a little more than 24 hours after the apartments on the top floor had taken a direct hit from one of Hamas’ Grad missiles, killing three people. As of Sunday, the dead are Israel’s only fatalities since the launch last week of Operation Pillar of Defense.

The Israeli offensive, which started with the killing of the senior military commander of Hamas and has targeted the terrorist group’s governing infrastructure and left more than 60 Palestinians dead, aims to stop the rocket fire raining down on Israel from Gaza. Last week, those rockets reached the outskirts of Tel Aviv and Jerusalem for the first time.

In Kiryat Malachi, the ill-fated apartment building, like others in the low-income Har Chabad neighborhood, contains aging apartments and a peeling yellow exterior. Now its highest floors look like a scene out of 1980s Beirut: a bare skeleton of concrete framing a gaping hole where people used to live.

“Can you get a ladder?” yells Chaim Shteiner, one of the men in a yellow vest. Maybe the remains of the dead are stuck in the next tree, inside clothes that hang from burnt branches.

“They go all over the place,” Shteiner says. “I feel bad, but this is what you have to do.”

Kiryat Malachi’s deputy mayor, Shteiner also is a member of the city’s haredi Orthodox Chabad-Lubavitch community, founded about 30 years earlier to reach out to a growing population of Russian immigrants here.

As Shteiner picks through leaves, 22-year-old Moshe Zackles stands next to a small table on the building’s other side, offering a pair of tefillin to passers-by. Unlike Shteiner, Zackles wears the traditional Chabad uniform — a black wide-brimmed hat and matching suit.

The tefillin serves, he says, as a spiritual antidote to the raw physical tragedy — the “expression of the Jewish people, a symbol.”

Now Chabad needs some outreach as well. Two of the three victims — Aharon Smadja and Mira Scharf — were Lubavitchers. Along with her husband, Scharf had been doing outreach in New Delhi, India, where four years earlier to the day terrorists had killed the Chabad emissaries in Mumbai, Rabbi Gavriel and Rivka Holtzberg, as part of a broad terrorist attack.

Shteiner says he feels shaken but undeterred.

“This is holy work,” he says. “We feel we are on a mission. When you’re on a mission, you get strength from the people who sent you and from above.”

Minutes later, a siren blares across the neighborhood, growing louder as the seconds pass. Shteiner and his crew leap over a ledge and press their backs against the building’s rear wall, taking cover under an overhang. For the moment it is the safest place they can find.

After half a minute that feels like 10, they hear the boom, nowhere near them. Shteiner exhales.

“They don’t give us rest,” he says. The crowd is already dispersing. The third victim’s funeral begins in 10 minutes.

The slow procession to the cemetery brings together Lubavitchers in suits and young Sephardic men in T-shirts and jeans. Elderly religious women wearing headscarves walk alongside secular Russian immigrants.

Shteiner calls Kiryat Malachi “one big neighborhood,” and more than 100 residents pack a small, exposed building to mourn 24-year-old Itzik Amsalem, a newly religious yeshiva student.

Men sob on each other’s shoulders in a tight embrace. A woman walks arm in arm with a girl, lamenting the “hit after hit, hit after hit,” that southern Israel has absorbed in the days and years before that Friday afternoon.

The weeping continues while a Chabad rabbi, Yaakov Shvika, eulogizes Amsalem — “a great wound, an incredible wound.”

Minutes after Kiryat Malachi’s mayor, Moti Malka, takes the podium, another siren blares. Mourners scramble in the crowded building. Most take cover once more under the roof and against its only walls.

The chaos only grows after the rocket from Gaza explodes in the distance. After the siren, it seems the sadness has turned to rage.

“Disengagement criminals!” scream the men who had been crying, turning their curses against those who led Israel’s 2005 withdrawal from the Gaza Strip, the so-called disengagement, into a chant.

Calls for silence add to the cacophony.

“Conquer the strip!” the men yell, obscuring the rest of Malka’s eulogy for Amsalem.

Quiet returns by the time Likud Party Knesset member Michael Eitan, a Cabinet minister, addresses the crowd. But the mood has not changed.

While Eitan declares that the terrorists “want to rain fear on us, but they won’t succeed,” the chants of the crowd and the sound of the siren linger in the air. For the roomful of mourners, the next rocket is not far away.

Video: Nachlat Har Chabad residents, led by activist Boruch Marzel, chase away Al-Jazeera reporters who came to film news footage and conduct interviews

7 Comments

  • Not normal

    I feel like I’m reading a horror book. System failure and the bad guys get 3 of us. Is this real???? We need moshiach.

  • Mistakes happen

    If 3 people were r”l killed because of a malfunction of a half hour, imagine how many lives it saves when it’s working properly…

  • PLEASE READ AND REREAD

    As one with experience in the IDF, I must tell you that this report, though may be true and accurate, brings two issues to the fore.

    A. Though we don’t comprehend it, this is H’s holy will. Im H’ lo yishmor ish, shov shokad shomer.

    B. Not of any less importance – the missile interception project is run by young soldiers whom are conciensious and extremely emotionally sensitive. They understand the gravity of their work, and any failure, including the one that resulted in the loss of three heilige neshomes, causes these brave soldiers EXTREME DISTRESS, to the point of irreversible psychological disorders! Some may even commit suicide (CHV“SH) to escape the tormenting guilt. As matter of fact, ask any soldier who has returned from a military operation ”did you shoot any person from the enemy side?“ If he has, he will avoid talking about it, and show obvious signs of distress. If he freely talks about his ”military accomplishments,” he’s probably inventing stories, or is extremely callous. Statistically – the former.

    Please post and report the SUCCESSFUL INTERCEPTIONS, then thank H’ for the chochmo he imparted with the greatest army in the world, and also thank these young precious neshomes – the soldiers who can be sitting in colleges, clubs, parks, etc. but instead spend their time defending the Land of Israel, G-d’s gift to the chosen people, AND ULTIMATELY, THE HEILIGE TORAH TOO!!!

    I humbly request that more sensitivity is practiced when choosing articles to report. It touches a severely sore spot in many who have merited in serving Klal Yisroel and Eretz Yisroel.

  • Resident of Israel

    I live in Israel. I have heard the air raid sirens. I have had to run to my safe room in my basement and wait the suggested ten minutes in case of falling shrapnel.
    For you to blame the death of these souls on an Iron Dome failure is bizarre. G-d decided who lives, and G-d decides who dies.
    It is beyond tragic that these 3 people died. BEYOND TRAGIC. But to blame it on an Iron Dome failure is ridiculous! It is G-d! G-d decides who lives, and G-d decides who dies. Not the 18-19 year olds who operate the Iron Dome. G-d decides life or death!!!!

  • its not only the iron dome

    They were standing outside,… its too bad they didnt go to a shelter/suggested stairway to keep safe Please pray for israel

  • Mendell

    They had more than one minute to get to safety in the stairwell – as publicized over and over and over here – and they did not go. Do not blame Iron Dome or HaShem.