AP
Left: New York Governor Andrew Cuomo. Right: New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio.

Mayor De Blasio, Governor Cuomo Spar on Taxes

New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio surrounded himself with labor leaders Monday morning, the latest choreographed show of support for his signature campaign promise to fund universal pre-kindergarten programs with a tax increase on the wealthy.

But at that exact moment, the person whose backing he most needs assembled his own news conference about 150 miles to the north and positioned himself behind a banner that read “Cutting Taxes for New Yorkers.”

Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo’s reluctance to raise taxes pits the state’s two leading Democrats against each other and endangers the central plank of de Blasio’s liberal agenda. Though de Blasio’s proposed tax would only impact New York City residents, it won’t become law without the blessing of the state Legislature and Cuomo.

The governor, who is up for re-election and may be eyeing a White House run, again gave no indication that he is willing to support de Blasio’s tax increase, instead devoting his Albany news conference to various corporate and property tax cuts meant to make the state more welcome to businesses.

Cuomo has long signaled his support for his universal pre-kindergarten but has not committed to a way to fund it. He called it a “two-step process.”

“First, decide what you want to do,” Cuomo told reporters. “And step two is decide how you are going to do it. I think we’re on step one, which is I’m in agreement with the mayor that pre-K is the direction that this state has to head.”

“The question comes: How do we pay for it?” asked Cuomo.

Cuomo has not committed to a timetable for any universal pre-kindergarten plan while de Blasio wants the tax increase included in this year’s spring budget so the program can be unveiled this September.

“The governor has made a very clear commitment to pre-K and I commend him for it,” said de Blasio, who wants to raise the income tax on New Yorkers who make more than $500,000 a year from 3.876 percent to 4.41 percent. “That is different from reaching every child in New York City here and now.”

The relationship between Cuomo and de Blasio is one of the most closely watched in state politics.

The men, who are close in age, frequently refer to each other as “friend” and de Blasio speaks glowingly about the time he worked for Cuomo in the federal Department of Housing and Urban Development under former president Bill Clinton. Cuomo endorsed de Blasio for mayor but waited until the Democratic primary was over.

Cuomo denied a media report that he was going to introduce his own universal pre-kindergarten program in his State of the State speech on Wednesday though he could propose another way to pay for the plan.

De Blasio has steadfastly refused to consider an alternative means of funding.

“We believe it’s the right thing to do,” the mayor said Monday. “We are sticking to this goal. We’re not going to bargain against ourselves.”

“This is dedicated funding for five years,” he said. “We don’t want to do this year-by-year. We don’t want half-measures. We don’t want partial funding. And we believe this is a fair and just way to do it. And if there’s other resources available in Albany, I assure you we have plenty of other needs for them, in our schools and beyond.”

De Blasio is expected to negotiate further with Cuomo when he travels to Albany on Wednesday for the governor’s address.

3 Comments

  • declasse' intelectual

    This ought to play out in the most interesting way. The State of New York has an official program to promote business opportunities and growth in New York through tax credits and other incentives. The major issue is that in New York one could, theoretically, pay over 60 percent of earned income in taxes to federal state and city governments–which is one of the major factors behind the promote business campaign.
    One of the major downsides to the Mayor’s proposal would be to encourage many not to move into the city and others to leave; it has occurred in other places where people and buisnesses have left owing to rising taxes. If the mayor gets his way–it will occur again.

  • they did this in Canada

    The Premier in Ontario raised taxes to bring in free junior kindergarten and almost destroyed a previously debt free province.

    He made a mess of things, created a huge deficit and is now taking it out on the doctors and cutting back on healthcare.