In a late Erev Shabbos announcement Rabbi Avrohom Osdoba said that he will not be attending the Hachtorah of R. Yosef Braun Sunday evening in 770, and he declared that others shouldn’t attend as well.
Rabbi Osdoba Declares: “I will Not Attend the Hachtorah, nor Shall Others”
In a late Erev Shabbos announcement Rabbi Avrohom Osdoba said that he will not be attending the Hachtorah of R. Yosef Braun Sunday evening in 770, and he declared that others shouldn’t attend as well.
In his announcement, via telephone, Rabbi Osdoba said that “since there were serious questions posed to Rabbi Rosenberg and the Beis Din, by both myself and others and there have been no clear answers yet. And therefore the Hachtorah should be postponed and I will not be attending, and other should not attend either.”
This development comes on the heels of the latest Twitter post by Yossi Hackner where he asserts that the Vaad is currently being run as a one man show with Zaki Tamir alone at the helm. In his tweet he says that according to Fishel Brownstein Tamir is indeed running his own show.
An additional tweet by Hackner says that he received a phone call from Shmuel Chanin saying that Tamir is running his own show, but he wants Chanin to try and get the other two Vaad members behind him.
Tachliss
Call Homeland Security, tell them someone is flying into New York to explode a whole neighborhood.
Close 770 at 6:00pm Sunday; Have security ban any entry; Have Homeland security go through every little peice and nook, cranny, toilets and all.
In a week, 770 can be opened again to “tag” bering citizens.
The only way.
Private property is not for public abuse.
Shomer Shabbos?????!!!!
So now Sam Chanin is running the community? Is he even a Shomer Shabbos? He doesn’t wear a Yarmulke at work and he isn’t a CH resident.
Zaki, you need to resign.
bottom line
according to halacha you must listen to your local rov over another rov outside the community as well as a lubavitcher over a non-lubavitcher!!
so if rabbi osdobo says not to go you cant go
sam
och un vey if Shmuli Chanin is our Leaders adviser and Brown seporter
every one should have a good shabes and fabreing yud shvat with emese chasidishe ruach
great comment
tachliss, I love your suggestions!!!!!
show me the money
Zaki isaac Tamir has been corrupted with money.
He came in to the CHJCC, chanina Sperlin told him that if he is part of the gang, he will show Zaki how to funnel the money.
Thats why Chanina Sperlin and Eli Cohen are still there.
integrity
#1-good idea if you’re serious. Do they have enough guts to show intergity for justice?
azkir al hatzion
azkir al hatzion – may we be zoche to see the rebbe asap if not now.
ceo
oh please send the rebbe, because it seems that those who are suposed to be protecting us all, and especially the vulnerable and needy….and all in our shechuna, need guidance with doing what the Rebbe wants. This is not what the Rebbe wants. Something is rotten at the core here, and this is an insult to the Rebbe and to yidden. NEBACH
how could haner be in vaad he has beard
Zaki Isaac B. Tamir is a chosid of his brother in law on a mission to destroy Crown Heights.
and yes the mechalel shbbos (when he takes a yarmulkeh from his pocket its with Yechi)
Muleh Chanin will be the RABBI
disgusted
I’m wondering why Aguch is allowing 770 to be used in this way. On the other hand, they are so weak they’ve allowed all sorts of appalling behavior for the past 16+ years, so why should this circus be any different?
Sam Chanin…not exactly a shining star of frumkeit, is he? And he’s now calling the shots? Interesting. I guess if you are an oisfarf but you have a few bucks you can manipulate the Bais Din & a whole community.
This whole thing is a shanda. No one of these lowlifes cares a jot about the Rebbe or what he gave his entire life for. On Yud Shvat this is what these people are doing? I’m so sickened at the corruption that is rampant & open. They don’t even try to hide it any more.
e. ezaqui
the rebbe had enough. this is why he moved to queens.
Sam Chanin the Mishichist
Sam Chanin doesn’t believe in g-d but he knows for a fact that the Rebbe is Moshiach!
A Mishichiat is a mishichist no matter what he believe. The Mishichist party has nothing to do with believe, it’s all about money and power!
auntie
ENOUGH LOSHON HARA, ENOUGH ENOUGH ENOUGH
just find whats right and do it.
what are you all, blind and farshtupt?? Timtum halev and more
Its wrong, it doent matter who says it i
If i get pulled over and given a false ticket by a cop, even if a judge upholds it, it doesn’t make it right.
If 1 out of 5 zabla members and 1 out of 3 vaad members say that Braun is a Rov, that doesn’t make him one!
Not a Rabbi Schwei fan either
I never thought I’d ever agree with Rabbi Osdoba on anything, but in this I’m with him 100%. Braun shouldn’t be allowed here.
the money
It’s all about the money, where is the money?
millions that belong to the residents of crown heights gone missing!
chleaks.com
why yud shvat time? because...
“A ceremony for Rabbi Braun was planned for this Motzoei Shabbos, Yud Shvat, but the only available flight to fit the schedule would still be in air on Shabbos, CrownHeights.info was told, so Rabbi Braun’s trip had to be postponed.” said zaki tamir.
why was it planned for motzoei shabbos? simple, because a) being that the main farbrengen is held motzoei shabbos, this assures the biggest crowd than any other night B) if rabbi osdoba will not attend, and encourage others not to attend, there would anyway be many people since the main farbrengen is taking place then.
now that it cant be done on motzoei shabbos, they are making it sunday night because A) many people will still be there because its right after yud shvat B) if rabbi osdaba says he wont attend and will encourage others not to attend, many will still be there for a yud shvat farbrengen.
this is why the schwei camp wont wait a little longer ( a week or two) when there can be a response from rabbi Rozenberg. because later there might just be a very very small crowd – if rabbi osdaba shlit”a boycotts the hachtorah.
may there be peace… asap if not now. azkir al hatzion bli neder.
Y. Cohen
THIS IS AN EYE OPENER TO ALL
I for one always respected zaki as I thought he campaigned to help the community with no agenda. It seemed he was doing it with pure intentions. I now feel like a victim of fraud.
On friday he was quoted on this site and col saying that Rabbi Osdoba will be coming to the hachtora. This was obviously a LIE as rabbi osdoba came out against on the very same day. I normally refrain from posting but this really stinks.
We are a community and our kids don’t need to see this
chaim ber
crown heights has major issues!
#1 we all voted one guy in and now they are getting cold feet
#2 money taks here in town! sam chanin is funding crown heights beis din, why?>??
#3 vote all three rabbim out and start again
#4 how does one rov over ride 2 other elected rabbonim? let rabbi osdoba and whoever eles who disagree not show up
#5 rabbousyia it makes no difference who the rov is, nobody is going to listen
agutten voch
No Q
How can there be a question on this??? You can’t have people going to a Rav for piskie halacha if he is not a Rav. I can’t understand for one second how anyone who is a yiras shomayim could think otherwise…
ch resident
why are we letting outsiders like braun, rosenberg run our community?
even tamir is not a real lubavitcher. he does not look like one. it is embarrassing what our community council members look like and those of other frum communities.
braun must be desperate to even what to come where he is obviously not wanted.
people stop playing games. this is real life. our community is a churban. why are we making it even worse by allowing him to come? rosenberg stop making a fool of us. you made about $500,000 off of our community. leave while you are ahead. we are lubavitch, the holiest of chassidim. keep it this way. do not let outsiders tell us what to do. get rid of the garbage.
wow!!!!!
wow why do rabbanim want people to listen to them if they dont listen to others????!!!!!
Outraged
Mr. Hackner being voted in as a Va’ad member, you may want to find a better way to communicate with the other Va’ad members in a professional manner, tweeting may not be the most direct and effective method.
As for Tamir, he may be following the Mishna’s instructions “bimokom shein ish…”
Lastly, it is utterly despicable to read posts written by other residents that are saturated in blind and malicious hatred.
leimeh
zei zugen, az broin is a whacko lichol hapochis. nu nu. moshiach now
feldman
brain was the baal machlokos in sydney good luck CH
Watch and laugh
I can’t wait till Braun gets here. The entertainment gets better and better here in the hood! Barnum & Baily’s circus has real competition in 770.
With today’s economy, who doesn’t appreciate some free laughs?
Uncle Mendel
It’s not Pesach Yet, but I havefour questions regarding all this ‘Show’;
1. When did the show start?
2. Why wasn’t I invited to the Previews?
3. Are they serving anything to eat? If so, what?
4. What time is the show over?
Visit us at Arlans when you leave !!!