8:00pm: Our Troubled Youth; Mental Illness; Criticizing Others

This week’s edition of MyLife: Chassidus Applied with Rabbi Simon Jacobson, Episode 80, will air tonight, Sunday, here on CrownHeights.info, beginning at 8:00pm. This week Rabbi Jacobson will address the topics: Our Troubled Youth; Mental Illness; Criticizing Others.

The tragic suicide of Faigy Mayer, among other recent tragedies (more than the public is aware of), has brought to the fore many critical questions. What anguish would cause someone to take their own life? How should we be dealing with our troubled youth? Is there anyone to blame? How responsible are parents, family and our school systems? What role does mental illness —and the way we do or don’t deal with it – play in all this? Are we properly handling mental illness, especially considering the deep stigma and shame associated with it? Families and communities are being vilified for not creating a nurturing environment for our young people facing challenges. But is this accurate, or just a scapegoating campaign? With much talk about what’s lacking in the community and causing youth to leave yiddishkeit, what about the other end of the spectrum: Are the organizations and support groups for these people creating a healthy environment for them, helping them build functional lives or are they simply perpetuating the negative sentiments they harbor?

In this episode of MyLife Rabbi Jacobson will begin addressing these thorny and complex issues. Other topics that will be addressed include criticizing others and can one be frum and gay.

Where do we draw the line between the mitzvah of “rebuking your neighbor” and inappropriately criticizing others? Why are people mixing into other people’s business? “I have been to several homes where the topic of conversation at the Shabbos table, in the presence of all the kids, is not on the Parsha or a chassidishe story or hergesh, but about the flaws of others. Can you please address this and its negative effects.”

Rabbi Jacobson will also review the following essays submitted in the MyLife: Chassidus Applied contest: “Productive Self-Evaluation” byMenachem Mendel Chalili, “Controlling One’s Feelings by Separating them from the Facts” by Esther Gur, and “The Power of Persistent Positive Thought” by Chana Kalachi.  These and other essays can be read online at meaningfullife.com/mylife/contest/.

And finally, the Chassidus question of the week (our new feature): I don’t fully see the difference between Kabolas ol, Iskafya and Mesiras Nefesh (mesiras ratzon). Can you please explain the different approaches? Thank you.

This hour-long dose of insights is meant to inform, inspire and empower us by applying the teachings of Chassidus to help us face practical and emotional challenges and difficulties in our personal lives and relationships. To have your question addressed, please submit it atwww.meaningfullife.com/mylife.

The topics in this Sunday’s hour-long broadcast will include:

  • Chassidus Applied to Elul and Parshas Shoftim
  • Our troubled youth: Who is responsible?
  • Mental illness and its stigma
  • Can I be frum and homosexual?
  • Criticizing others
  • Follow-up: Laziness and Homeschooling
  • Chassidus Question of the week: the difference between Kabolas Ol, Iskafiya and Mesiras Nefesh
  • MyLife Essays: Productive self-evaluation; Controlling feelings by separating them from the facts; The Power of Persistent Positive Thought

MyLife: Chassidus Applied addresses questions that many people are afraid to ask and others are afraid to answer. When asked about the sensitive topics he has been addressing, Rabbi Simon Jacobson commented, “I understand that the stakes are high, but the silence and lack of clarity on matters plaguing the community can no longer go unaddressed. The stakes of not providing answers are even higher.”

The on-going series has provoked a significant reaction from the community, with thousands of people viewing each live broadcast and hundreds of questions pouring in. At the root of every question and personal challenge tackled by the series is the overarching question: Does Judaism have the answers to my personal dilemmas?

In inimitable “Jacobson-fashion”, the broadcast answers people’s questions in simple, clear language while being heavily sourced. Each episode is jam-packed with eye-opening advice from the Rebbeim, gleaned from uncovering surprising gems in their letters, sichos, and maamorim that address our personal issues with disarming relevance. Simultaneously, Rabbi Jacobson is able to crystallize a concept quickly, succinctly, and poignantly for any level of listener.

All episodes are immediately available for viewing in the MLC’s archive and can be downloaded as MP3’s for listening on the go.

Questions may be submitted anonymously at www.meaningfullife.com/mylifelive.

MyLife is now available as a podcast and can be streamed or downloaded from iTunes.

4 Comments

  • gw

    great system to be able to bring up concerns.
    there are sooooo MANY.
    may we get more clarity in all areas. thanks alot.

  • Darchei Noam

    In a prevous blog about similar topics, one of them was, as is also now, homosexuality. I blogged a stinging commentary on how, incrementally, the liberals succeeded in brainwashing society into accepting this as normal as heterosexual.

    A fellow blogger complained that I was zealous and aggressive, and that it would be more efffective if I would be more “darchei noam.” Granted, that may be the case, that I was blunt, calling them perverts…

    Okay, I can’t think of a better Darchei Noam, other
    than the Rebbe, ZY”A. See his treatise on this matter:

    https://guardyoureyes.com/resources/ssa/item/letter-from-the-lubavitcher-rebbe-about-ssa

    Now, let me clarify something. I have no hateful feelings towards anyone, who, through no fault of their own, this is how they developed. In fact, when a co-worker said he was gay (responding to the topic of marriage, which I brought up), I treated him just like anyone else.

    What really gets me so upset over this is as follows:
    What they are doing is shoving it down the nations’ throat, that you have to accept this as normal and okay, otherwise, you are a bigot, racist; get fired, lose membership in clubs; fined over 100k if you don’t cater to their “weddings” on religious grounds, etc. This has happened and is still happening. There is a big “re-education” effort, even to first-graders, to make this, not just acceptable, but even glorified.

    To me, this is unacceptable. It would be no different than Anita Bryant demanding that we accept J. as our “saviour,” otherwise we burn in Hell, get fired from our job, etc. Anita Bryant was a Christian anti-gay activist, famous for getting an ordinance in Dade County, Fl, which prohibited discrimination against gays, repealed (1977).

    How do you like that? Then the Christians would have a right to demand a Jewish caterer providing a cake for one of their religious events, Religious Moslems would have to cater to Yom HaAtzmus…

  • Mental Illness

    There is a famous Chazal which says:

    “There is something which is not a mitzva, but can
    lead to the greatest of mitzvos. This is Mikva.

    There is something which is not an aveira, but
    can lead to the greatest of aveiros. This is
    depression.”

    I suppose, depending on the severity of the depression, will be the severity of the aveira.
    In the case of severe depression, would you put it
    past even Moshe Rebbenu, ZT”L, to take his own life, or even challenging the Ribono Shel Olam,CH”V?

    Yes, I would think that depression may be the culprit, in the MAJORITY of cases, why there is so much loss of our precious youth and neshamos. B”H, there is lots of help for it, and it behooves anyone afflicted with this to go to a medical professional (best a psychiatrist; that’s their specialty) for treatment. Depending on what’s causing it will be the remedy (e.g. medication, counseling, holistic,exercise, etc., or a comination of 2 or more modalities).